Why I’d take a newborn over a toddler any day

Posted in Newborn.

Maybe its just me, but newborns seem to get a bad wrap a lot of the time. I often hear new mothers lamenting the fractured sleepless nights, heavy dependence, lack of personal space and farewelling of all spontaneity. Dont get me wrong, those things are hard and they definitely take some time to adjust to, especially when it comes to surrendering to what we cannot control.

And sure, perhaps its because I myself have been through this stage of raising children four times now and have lived to see the other side; but Id take a newborn over a toddler any day! (Which is probably why I had so many children …)

Why is that, you ask?

Firstly, they don’t talk

Yeah, sometimes they cry. In fact, this may even go on for extended periods of time. But whilst having a precious small human crying in your arms can be stressful, I still prefer it to the constant chatter and whining (oh the whining!) that comes when the small baby grows into a toddler. Babies dont talk, so that means adult conversations can actually occur. Conversations can exist with your significant other that are actually meaningful and nourishing. But when you are the parent of a toddler, you have to practically schedule in a time to talk in between the incessant babble. Between meeting their ongoing demands which change depending on the time of day and even their mood, navigating tantrums and setting constant boundaries – phew!

Mother talking to toddler at the park feature

They’re just so … portable

Another thing I love about newborns is how portable they are. Because they cant, you know, walk – or run! They can hang out on your hip, suckle in your arms at the milk bar while you lay back on the couch or they can hang out in a carrier or a sling. They can even be fairly well contained on a rug on the floor and they dont move. Its fabulous – a stage which sadly just doesnt seem to last long enough. Toddlers on the other hand seem to not only create havoc and distraction but its almost like chaos is something that they actually seek out. And dont even try to contain them! Toddlers are innately curious, unstoppable forces of nature that buckle from being restrained because it goes against their natural learning instincts. Which brings me to my final point.

You are their entire world

I love newborns because at the end of the day all they really need is just you, their mama. You are their entire world. All the comfort, nourishment and safety that they desire in their world can come solely from you. Whilst I understand that this can sometimes seem like an enormous amount of pressure to manage not to mention a huge responsibility, in all honesty it really is an honour. Toddlers on the hand, change their needs and wants on a minute-to-minute basis. They are unpredictable and bring exhaustion to a whole new level. With a newborn, its fairly safe to assume that if theyre unhappy its because theyve pooped, need to feed or are tired. When a toddler is unhappy its pretty much a matter of throwing random ideas and suggestions out into the universe until one meets their whim. Relaxing, right?

toddler kissing mother's forehead

The toddler years are definitely tougher

The positive news is that there is at least theres a fairly logical reason why toddlers can seem so challenging. Its because they’re learning about their world and seeking guidance from their parents to find out where they fit in it. So whilst I lament these exhausting years of negotiations and constant problem-solving, they really are laying the foundations for years to come. I know it does pay off, and the milky memories of a sweet-smelling newborn snuggled against my chest will help get me through.


Get more babyology straight to your inbox