Mum’s big move: “Christmas is cancelled. For now! Say sorry.”

Mum's note cancelling Christmas

An end-of-her-tether Queensland mum has put her foot down, wrapping the family Christmas tree in plastic and tacking up a note from Elsie the Elf to advise her kids “Christmas is cancelled for now”.

Mum's note saying Christmas is cancelled


Let’s face it, most parents have probably almost been where this frazzled mum was when she took this drastic action.

Many of us have found ourselves warning our children that Santa won’t come or they might be on the “naughty list” or that Father Christmas is watching. This mum just pushed things a little bit further into unfamiliar festive territory.

“Christmas is cancelled for now!” her ‘from Elsie the Elf’ note advised, in Sharpie as black as unwanted coal in a hopefully-hung Christmas stocking. “If you want me to keep visiting, a Santa visit and your tree and presents back, your behaviour needs to improve. Santa is very angry and I’m disappointed. BE GOOD and say sorry to mum. You all have ONE week to improve. I’m watching. – Elsie, Creepy McCreep Face”

Gulp. We have to admit this has actually scared the willies out of us, so we can’t imagine how the kids in question felt.

The experts weigh in

A photo of these heart-stopping Christmas consequences was shared on the ABC Brisbane Facebook page and followers immediately began weighing in on the wisdom of this approach.

While experts warned against similar drastic festive action, many parents were nodding and muttering things like “I hear you, girlfriend” as they surveyed their own living rooms, brimful of challenging and exhausted kids.

“I think that we get into dangerous waters when we speak on behalf of Santa Claus or his elves,” parenting authority Dr Michael Carr-Gregg told the ABC.

“The general principle of there being consequences for bad behaviour I agree with 100 per cent. Just not this way. Christmas is a time for family, peace, love and good will … and to turn it into a punitive toll takes some of the gloss off Christmas.”

Have you ever cancelled Christmas on your kids? 🎄One Queensland parent has done it "for now". This morning their three…

Posted by ABC Brisbane on Monday, 4 December 2017

Mixed reviews

The Facebook commenters on the ABC Brisbane page had varying responses to this mum’s firm festive act.

Some thought she should stop hiding behind Santa and crack out the wooden spoon (to be clear, it’s not okay to smack anyone, least of all children).

“Stop lying to your kids with fairytales. Give them a spanking if they’re being disobedient then enjoy Christmas,” one man posted angrily.

Some figured that this was a total parenting fail, perhaps out of touch with the challenges of parenting small children.

“Obviously a loveless family. Naughty kids are usually crying out for attention,” another (freaking judgemental) man said.

Some were issuing a high-five from afar, but had not quite crossed this line.

“Very close to it at the moment with finances being so tight and the kids playing up,” a sympathetic dad commented.

Others saw the silver lining. Or the silver bauble, really.

“For all of those with toddlers this is a great way to keep the baubles on the tree,” one practical mum posted.

Others still considered this excellent parenting.

“As a mother of 5, foster Mum of 2, Granny of 13 and a great grandmother I say well done. Its great to see a parent in control,” a feisty granny wrote.

What do you think? Tough love gone too far? Or an act of genius?

Subscribe to Babyology

Our email newsletters keep you up to date with what’s happening on Babyology.

We also have special newsletter-only offers and competitions that are exclusive to Babyology subscribers.

Sign up below:

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Send this to a friend